Left Behind

Tuesday's World Events   —   Posted on November 28, 2005

(by Priya Abraham, WorldMag.com) – Call America Online’s technical support, and a customer will likely get a phone agent with a name like Steve, or CJ, or Shane. They are all American-sounding names, but the agents are all Indian. One named “Jason” acknowledged his real name was Jitu. He was at a Mumbai (formerly Bombay) call center, working the graveyard shift at around 3 a.m. The alias was for customer satisfaction surveys: “Americans don’t remember our names,” he explained.

For all the hard hours, Jitu’s is the kind of job that is swelling India’s middle class and growing the country’s $17.2 billion outsourcing industry. Such jobs may offer about $200 a month and plush office buildings with pingpong tables, gyms, free food, and rides to and from work. The jobs are helping to make India’s economy one of the fastest-growing in the world, expected to expand about 7 percent this year. But while globalization brings the good life to millions of Indians, millions more – pinned down by the Hindu caste system – are simply watching it zip by.

Broadly, Hindus are divided into four castes: the Brahmins, or priestly class, at the top; Kshatriyas, or warriors, second; Vaishyas, or merchants and artisans, third; and Shudras, or unskilled laborers, at the bottom. The most despised, the “untouchables,” were too lowly even to register in the hierarchy, the original outcasts. Layered in between the four classes are thousands of sub-castes.

Although India officially abolished the caste system at independence in 1949 and legally provided equal access to state jobs, schooling, and political representation for lower castes, distinctions and discrimination linger strongly in the culture. Now they are hindering the poorest from tapping into the opportunities propelling higher-caste Indians into 21st-century prosperity.

Now known as “Dalits,” untouchables number about 250 million and still suffer bone-crushing poverty, beatings, rapes, and other abuses. They perform menial labor in fields such as hide-tanning and human sanitation, both considered polluting work in Hinduism, which emphasizes ritual purity. Add to them another 500 million low-caste Indians in mildly better conditions, and most of the nation’s 1 billion population is trailing behind the well-equipped middle and upper classes.

“The poor have become poorer and the Dalits have become more impoverished,” said Joseph D’souza, president of an international advocacy group, the Dalit Freedom Network. “Definitely, we have now the two Indias – one shining, and one in darkness.”

The darkness is thick for most Dalits: They subsist on $1 a day, and family needs drive parents to pull their children out of school to work. In elementary school, the dropout rate is about 60 percent; by 10th grade the rate climbs to 80 percent. India has some 25 million bonded child laborers, most of them low-caste. Under these circumstances, Mr. D’souza asks, “How do they become part of the globalized new economy?”

In addition to battling discrimination, English is also a roadblock for Dalits to the upper castes’ high-paying jobs. Most Dalits attend schools that teach in their local language. That can take them up through an undergraduate education, but not beyond. And the best jobs – such as the ones at call centers that require fluent English – will never be open.

“Many postgraduates are unemployed because of the language problem,” said Kancha Ilaiah, a political science professor at Osmania University in Hyderabad. The 53-year-old comes from a low shepherds’ caste in Andhra Pradesh, and he sees a difference between his youth and today’s: “Compared to my generation there is more and more frustration. India is likely to move in the direction of Paris now.”

Mr. Ilaiah is blunt about the security threat a disaffected population can pose. On Oct. 6, he testified before a subcommittee of the House Committee on International Relations, identifying Islam and Marxism as attractive alternatives for low-caste Hindus: “In the 1970s many low-caste people adopted a violent Maoist identity. Calling themselves Naxalites, these Dalits began to use the theory of counter-violence through the Maoist movement. The Maoist movement continues to use violent means such as car bombs and landmines to kill and intimidate.” The struggle between Maoist guerrillas and Nepal’s monarchy, for example, has plunged the Himalayan nation into chaos.

Also couched in the larger Dalit struggle is a particular activist concern for those who convert to Christianity. India has its own system of affirmative action: The government fills a certain percentage of its public-service jobs with Dalits. While Dalit converts to Sikhism and Buddhism are eligible for the quota and other protections, Christian converts are not. The reasoning, under a 1950 presidential order, is this: Since the Dalits joined a religion that does not practice caste, they are no longer subject to discrimination.

Dalit activists say that is a hollow argument. To powerful upper-caste Hindus, a Dalit is always a Dalit, regardless of what faith he professes. So this year, advocates lodged a Supreme Court petition requesting a review of the presidential order. In turn, the court has requested the government’s response. But since August, officials have delayed giving a response, with a new hearing scheduled for late November.

A favorable ruling would mean much more than just jobs, explains Moses Parmar, a Dalit pastor and director of Operation Mobilization in northern India. Recognized as Dalits, Christian Dalits would have protection under the tough Dalit Atrocities Act. For example, a man convicted of rape may get a few months in prison, but the Act prescribes 10-20 years for raping a Dalit woman. As attacks by Hindus intensify, such safeguards become more urgent. “Most of the Christians attacked are Dalit Christians,” Mr. Parmar said. With harsher penalties, “they will not dare to attack Christians.”

Activists are also pushing for affirmative action within India’s private sector to ensure that Dalits have access to the jobs the purring economy is creating. Mr. Ilaiah has recommendations for the United States. He suggests a portion of aid should go to Dalit English-language education and wants the U.S. to reserve a portion of the coveted work visas that go to Indians for Dalits.

Still, tougher laws are not enough to guarantee Dalit equality. Even when victims report crimes, the notoriously sluggish Indian legal system secures few prosecutions. Changing Hindu worldviews is a better – if more arduous – insurance policy.

Mr. Parmar, 43, knows the challenges well. He oversees 900 churches, and many of the rural ones with only dozens of members suffer vandalism and attacks from Hindus. Even matrimonial advertisements “for men and women seeking spouses”are not free from prejudice. “Even for a software engineer who comes from Silicon Valley—they want a bride who comes from their caste, sub-caste and even sub-sub-caste,” he said. “They’re very particular about it.”

Mr. Parmar also still endures the barbs that pricked his youth. When he returns to his hometown of Nadiad in Gujarat state, higher-caste childhood friends still give him separate cups and plates to use in their homes. He sometimes has to warn his fellow Dalits that it could take 30 or 40 years to change such attitudes. Until then, call centers and the middle class will stay in the other India.

Copyright 2005 WORLD Magazine, Dec. 3, 2005, Reprinted here with permission from World Magazine. Visit the website at WorldMag.com.

Questions

1.  Who are the Dalits?  What percent of the Indian population are Dalits?

2.  When was the caste system abolished in India?  What does article 17 of India’s constitution state about the status of “untouchable”?
(Click here for India’s constitution.)

3.  Why is the caste system still practiced when it was abolished by law over 50 years ago?

4.  What is outsourcing?  What types of jobs are outsourced from American companies to India?  Why don’t Dalits get these types of jobs?  Be specific.

5.  What is the Dalit Freedom Network?  In what ways does the Dalit Freedom Network help the untouchables? (For the website, go to Dalit Freedom Network.)

6.  Why are Dalits who convert to Christianity denied any of the public-service jobs reserved for Dalits?  Is this a fair argument?  Explain your answer.

7.  Hindus in India attack Christians (mostly Dalits).  How do activists propose to help Christian Dalits specifically?

8.  What suggestion does Kancha Ilaiah have for the U.S. government to help Dalits?  What suggestion does Priya Abraham have for for the best way to guarantee Dalit equality (para. 15)?  Do you agree with each suggestion?  Explain your answers.

For an article on a Dalit student, click here.


Free Answers — Sign-up here to receive a weekly email with answers.