(by Priya Abraham, WorldMag.com) – Evangelist Joseph Din stopped at home in Lahore, Pakistan, one Saturday afternoon after a preaching engagement, resting before his next prayer meeting with a local family. Din, 74, liked being back in Pakistan, where he could teach scripture in Urdu and people had time to listen. He missed that after seven years in the United States.
Visitors dropped by, and Din, who lived with his sister, forgot to lock the door after they left. Suddenly two young bearded menâ€”strangersâ€”barged in.
“Why are you coming here?” Din asked. The two paused halfway inside the room, pulled out a gun, and shot the elderly man twice in the chest. They tried to shoot Din’s sister, Nazir, but hit a wall instead. Din collapsed in his sister’s arms, blood streaming out. He died in surgery about an hour later.
Din’s death on Aug. 25 is one of several recent mysterious murders in Pakistan that may be linked to Islamic extremism. Persecution against Christians has climbed this year while the country as a whole shudders under political uncertainty. President Pervez Musharraf, the army head who has ruled since taking power in a 1999 coup, is under increasing pressure to share power and democratize.
On Oct. 6, Musharraf won a new term in an election boycotted by a resurgent opposition. Though he won, the general has endured broad discontent over his interference with the country’s Supreme Court. He has been forced to accept Benazir Bhutto, a two-time former prime minister, as a governing partner in her old position. Christians fared better under Bhutto, who is a moderate and a democrat, and hope her return will bring relief from this year’s fresh trouble.
Din lived in a Christian neighborhood of Lahore that seemed crime-ridden, his son Samson told WORLD. The murderers did not steal anything, even though Din’s sister begged them to take anything they wanted. Din’s son Samson, who lives in Virginia with his wife and infant twin sons, believes the men intended only to kill.
Does Samson think the men killed his father because he was Christian? “When I see other cases, I say yes,” he said. “We don’t have any enemies.”
Other cases involving Christians have been plenty in the last few weeks, though it is hard to determine if they were religious killings. Four days after Din’s death, a Muslim man shot dead pastor and wife Arif and Kathleen Khan in their home near Islamabad. On Sept. 27, another assailant shot and killed Col. Bo Brekke, the Salvation Army’s territorial commander of Pakistan, as he worked alone that evening in his office. In a statement, the organization said it appeared to be “an individual act of criminality.”
Whatever the motives, the worry is that the murderers will not see justice. Police have arrested no suspects in the Din case. General corruption and prejudice against Christians means police rarely capture the perpetrators in such cases. Where Muslims have attacked Christians for their faith, sometimes the police are in cahoots with the assailants, said Ann Buwalda, U.S. director of the Jubilee Campaign.
In the Khans’ case, some sort of personal grudge seemed at play: It was ex-church member Honey Haveed and his wife who aided in the murder. Police arrested the couple but have not caught the murderer and a third man, who fled to another province.
Reports said it was an honor killing, that Haveed falsely accused Khan of committing adultery with his wife. But even the speculation does not make sense, notes Buwalda. “If it’s an honor killing you don’t kill the pastor’s wife. You may kill the pastor, but you don’t kill the pastor’s wife.”
Political leadership aside, Pakistan’s Islamic laws make life hard for religious minorities. Pakistan’s Christians are poor and carry little political clout, often finding themselves harassed and charged for blasphemy against Islam. Impugning the name of Muhammad is punishable by death. When Bhutto was prime minister, during 1988-1990 and 1993-1996, no one was convicted of blasphemy in the country’s high court, Buwalda said. Her support also showed in quiet but valuable ways: Christians found their municipal services such as water and sewage treatment working.
“She had been very vocal in blasphemy cases, to the point that Muslims said she ought to be accused of blasphemy,” said Victor Gill, a Philadelphia-based political commentator and Pakistani Christian.
Bhutto, 54, is the elegant, Oxford-educated daughter of a former prime minister who has carried on her family’s political legacy. When she first came to power, the head of the military refused to look his new female leader in the eye, a sign of the hardships she would face heading a Muslim country. With this background, Bhutto has always been an ardent democrat and supporter of women’s rights.
Man or woman, Pakistan’s leaders do not last long without military backing, and Bhutto was ousted twice. She and other opposition leaders demanded that Musharraf resign as army head before the election; he said he would step down if he won. But the general is no fool, Gill says: “He knows if he takes his uniform off, he’s lost the gun.”
For his part, Musharraf has both helped and hindered religious minorities. To Washington’s dismay, he has made thorny alliances with Taliban-style Islamic radicals in Pakistan’s frontier provinces, which are at risk of breaking away. But when radicals threaten his power, he fights back: In the summer, government forces raided Islamabad’s Red Mosque, a hotbed of terrorists. The assault, Buwalda says, may be a reason that persecution of Christians has risen in recent months: Enraged Muslims are now pursuing “infidels.”
Though cozy with radicals, Musharraf has also pushed through more legal safeguards for religious minorities and rape victims, who had virtually no protection. He is like Bhutto in that respect, but the difference is Bhutto has always been tough on Muslim radicals. In her fallow years Bhutto lived in the Middle East, often touring the West and giving speeches on democracy in her trademark gossamer headscarves. As she readies to reenter Pakistan’s political stage, suffering Christians hope her presence will mean fewer deaths, and more living heroes like Joseph Din.
Pakistan: 2007 violence and intimidation against Christians
About 2 percent of Pakistan’s 147 million people are Christians. Most live in Punjab Province.
- June 17: About 40 Muslim men armed with guns, axes, and wooden sticks attack a Salvation Army Church north of Faisalabad for holding an evangelistic meeting, injuring seven. A month later, the attackers apologize.
- June 25: A prison halts Bible classes and puts Catholic prisoner Dil Awaiz in a high-security cell and tortures him after he teaches fellow Christian inmates to expect persecution. Muslim prisoners earlier protested that a Christian inmate drank out of one of their glasses. Christians are often considered unclean.
- Sept. 17: A judge unexpectedly acquits Christian teenager Shahid Masih of ripping up pages containing Quranic verses when Muslim witnesses against him back down. Radicals outside the courtroom are “very, very angry,” Masih’s defense lawyer says.
- Aug. 25: Two men shoot dead Pentecostal evangelist Joseph Din in his Lahore home. Din, a green-card holder, lived with his son in the United States about seven years before returning home to preach. Police have made no arrests.
- Aug. 29: A married couple and a man enter the home of Pastor Arif Khan and his wife Kathleen, shooting and killing both. The man, a Muslim, flees to South Waziristan Province and has yet to be caught.
- Sept. 27: A man shoots dead Salvation Army Col. Bo Brekke in his Lahore office. The organization says, “There is nothing to suggest that this is related in any way to terrorism.”
Copyright ©2007 WORLD Magazine, 10/20/07 issue. Reprinted here October 16th with permission from World Magazine. Visit the website at www.WorldMag.com.
1. a) Although no arrests have been made, what is believed to be the motive for the recent murders of several Christians in Pakistan?
b) Why do you think many people choose to ignore the real motive for the murder of Christians around the world?
2. Why doesn’t the reported motive for Arif and Kathleen Khan’s murder make sense?
3. Why will the murderers of these Christians probably not be brought to justice?
4. What hope do Christians have for improved safety in Pakistan under the renewed leadership of Prime Minister Benazir Bhutto?
5. During his rule, how has President Pervez Musharraf both helped and hindered Christians (and other religious minorities) in Pakistan?
6. What hope do you see for Christians who are persecuted for their faith in Pakistan?
For background information on Pakistan, go to the CIA World FactBook website at: cia.gov/library/publications/the-world-factbook/index.html
Benazir Bhutto was ousted twice as Prime Minister on charges of corruption, which she denies. Read about corruption charges against Ms. Bhutto at wikipedia.org/wiki/Benazir_Bhutto#Charges_of_corruption
Daily “Answers” emails are provided for Daily News Articles, Tuesday’s World Events and Friday’s News Quiz.