(by Jamie Dean, WorldMag.com) – For Perla Beltran, life isn’t easy: She lives in a gritty corner of New York City, has suffered the loss of her thieving husband, and recently fell in with a disreputable crowd. Fortunately for Beltran, there’s a government agency that can help: the U.S. Census Bureau.
If that sounds odd, it’s because Beltran’s saga is actually the plotline of a popular Spanish-language soap opera. Perhaps even odder: The U.S. Census Bureau helped develop the idea.
The unconventional pairing is part of the Census Bureau’s effort to encourage Hispanics to participate in the fast-approaching 2010 census. The bureau will begin mailing census forms to residents in all 50 states in March 2010. Officials aim to count all residents, including non-citizens.
For the bureau, that presents a challenge, especially if residents don’t speak English or fear reprisals if they’re in the country illegally. When it comes to Hispanics-the fastest-growing minority group in the country-the bureau is pouring millions of dollars into advertising campaigns and outreach efforts to assure residents that census information is private and confidential.
That’s exactly what an actor playing a census worker told Beltran on the Telemundo network’s popular soap opera Mas Sabe el Diablo, or The Devil Knows Best. In an episode airing later this fall, Beltran, played by actress Michelle Vargas, will become a census worker herself, brightening her dimming prospects. Along the way, the show will dispense information about the census aimed at encouraging viewers to participate.
Bureau officials say they helped the network develop the Beltran storyline by sending a staff member to meet with the show’s writer and by providing some props. While the bureau gets some free advertising, the network gets something too: The Nielsen Ratings system for television is tied to census results. The more Telemundo viewers fill out the census, the more the network will be able to prove audience growth to advertisers.
But the bureau isn’t just relying on soap operas and ads. For the first time, they’re also sending bilingual census forms to some 13 million homes in Spanish-speaking neighborhoods. The bilingual forms will contain the same questions included in English-only questionnaires. But despite the bureau’s massive efforts to reach Hispanic residents, there’s one question that won’t be on the form: Are you a U.S. citizen?
For some, that’s troubling for one central reason: Census population figures determine apportionment for congressional seats and the Electoral College. As states stand to lose or gain seats based on population growth, some say including illegal residents in that part of the count isn’t fair. The census hasn’t asked about citizenship for decades, but some say the question is more urgent since rates of illegal immigration have surged over the last two decades.
Census Bureau officials say they look to Congress for instructions about adding questions. Meanwhile, Congress has been lackluster about any changes. The only peep has come from Sen. Bob Bennett (R-Utah), who introduced a bill last month aimed at adding a citizenship question. But with the census less than six months away, the bureau is already printing forms.
As demographers debate the possible effects of illegal populations-and other trends-on congressional apportionment, one thing remains clear: The census remains a politically slippery issue with broad-reaching implications, even if some are gaining only tepid attention six months before the census begins.
Behind the scenes, tens of thousands of temporary workers have been joining census offices to finalize address listings and other details for a census expected to cost as much as $15 billion. Besides the new bilingual form, the bureau will introduce one other major change: Unlike the last three census rounds (1980, 1990, and 2000), officials will no longer mail a long version of the census with additional questions to a smaller number of households. Instead, they will send only a “short form” to each home.
To ask more detailed questions, the bureau has moved to its American Community Survey (ACS)-a questionnaire sent to 3 million households each year to gain a statistical sample on a host of questions. One of those questions is whether the resident is a citizen, but those numbers aren’t used in determining congressional representation.
The census information collected from the short form sent to every home will serve two primary purposes: apportioning congressional seats and allocating federal funds. The federal government will use population figures to award some $400 billion each year for projects like schools, roads, and extra police officers.
For Elliott Stonecipher, it’s the congressional seats he’s most worried about. The Louisiana demographer says based on last year’s data from the ACS, several states with a significant net gain in population from non-citizen populations include Texas, Nevada, Arizona, and Florida, all states with large numbers of illegal immigrants. Those states could gain more seats in the House, while other states, like Michigan, Ohio, Pennsylvania, and Louisiana, could lose a seat.
Election Data Services, a political consulting firm, predicts similar gains and losses but points to several factors, including immigration, migration from other states, and birth rates. The firm also emphasizes another factor that could make this census unusual: rampant foreclosures leading to population shifts and people who may be difficult to find for a count.
Though predictions about outcomes vary, Stonecipher says it makes sense to count everyone with the census, but to use only citizen population figures for congressional apportionment. Ira Mehlman of the Federation for American Immigration Reform agrees: “It’s just basically unfair to award additional representation in some states at the expense of people in other states who are citizens.”
Mehlman says he’s surprised the issue doesn’t raise more hackles: “You don’t hear any protests, and that baffles me.” The only protests from Congress so far have come from Bennett, the Utah Republican who wants the census to ask about citizenship and legal status. Census director Groves wouldn’t say whether he agreed with Bennett’s bill in principle, but he did say it’s impractical to implement six months before the census. “A lot of the forms are already printed,” Groves told The Salt Lake Tribune. “That train has left for the 2010 census clearly.”
When asked why the senator waited this long to introduce the bill, Bennett spokeswoman Andrea Candrian said the senator “moved quickly to introduce the bill as soon as he became aware of the problem.” Candrian said Bennett acknowledges it’s late in the process to revise the forms, but he suggests an addendum to the survey.
For both Republicans and Democrats, the issue is politically sensitive, with segments in both parties desiring to woo a growing demographic of Hispanics. But political speculation is tricky: Though Democrats typically win more of the Hispanic vote, apportionment with non-citizen populations tends to benefit red states more than blue ones.
While the Census Bureau reaches out to Hispanics, at least one Latino group is boycotting the census altogether: The National Coalition of Latino Clergy and Christian leaders is urging its members to boycott the census unless Congress passes immigration reform. The group’s leaders say boycotting the census would pressure congressmen in high-immigrant states to vote for reform or potentially lose political clout.
Most Hispanic groups are urging Hispanics to participate in the census. Samuel Rodriguez of the National Hispanic Association of Evangelicals says boycotting the census is counterproductive: “We’re conveying another message of isolationism rather than assimilation.” Rodriguez says a boycott would also prevent certain areas from gaining access to federal funds for things like more policemen and other services.
But though the minister supports the census, he says he doesn’t think it should ask about citizenship. Rodriguez says such a move would alienate Hispanics, both illegal and legal, and he questions whether immigrant populations will significantly affect apportionment numbers.
For now, Rodriguez doesn’t need to worry: The Senate Committee on Homeland Security and Governmental Affairs has yet to schedule a hearing for Bennett’s census bill.
Copyright ©2009 WORLD Magazine. Reprinted here October 13th from the October 24, 2009 issue with permission from World Magazine. Visit the website at WorldMag.com.
1. Define the following words as used in the article:
reprisal (para. 4)
apportionment (para. 8 & 10)
demographer (para. 10 & 14)
isolationism, assimilation (para. 21)
2. What problems does the Census Bureau face in getting some Hispanics to fill out the 2010 census?
3. How is the Census Bureau attempting to persuade Latinos to fill out census forms?
4. How will the Spanish language TV station Telemundo benefit from getting their viewers to fill out census forms?
5. a) What question is not on the census form?
b) Why is this a cause for concern?
c) Why do advocates say this question is even more important today that in past censuses?
6. Why do you think only one member of Congress is working to add a citizenship question to the census form?
7. How will counting all residents filling out census forms as citizens affect various states’ representation in the Federal government?
8. List the factors that might affect state population counts which will in turn determine the number of seats a state has in the U.S. House of Representatives.
9. Samuel Rodriguez of the National Hispanic Association of Evangelicals questions whether immigrant populations will significantly affect apportionment numbers. Do you agree with Mr. Rodriguez’s assertion?
10. a) For what purpose will the data from the census be used?
b) How important do you think it is to differentiate between citizens and illegal immigrants for the census? Explain your answer.
Census data are used to distribute Congressional seats to states, to make decisions about what community services to provide, and to distribute $400 billion in federal funds to local, state and tribal governments each year. (From the Census Bureau website)
WHAT? — Count
The census is a count of everyone residing in the United States: in all 50 states, the District of Columbia, Puerto Rico and the Island Areas.
WHO? — Everyone
All residents of the United States must be counted. This includes people of all ages, races, ethnic groups, citizens and non-citizens.
WHEN? — Every 10 years
WHERE? — Everywhere in the U.S.
The census counts everyone residing in the United States: in all 50 states, the District of Columbia, Puerto Rico and the Island Areas. People should be counted where they live and sleep most of the year.
The Census Bureau will mail or deliver questionnaires to your house in March 2010. We will mail a second form to households that do not respond to the initial questionnaire.
Households that still do not respond will be called or visited by a Census worker. (Census workers can be identified by a census badge and bag.)
Read “Why fill out the census form?” at 2010.census.gov/2010census/about_2010_census/007625.html.