TIME Magazine’s Jeff Sessions Cover

Wednesday's Example of Media Bias   —   Posted on April 25, 2018

TIME Magazine’s Jeff Sessions Cover

Jump to...

Print

Example of Media Bias:

Excerpted from a post by John A. Daly on March 29, 2018:

On March 29, TIME Magazine released a new issue featuring Attorney General Jeff Sessions. But the advertised in-depth interview is getting very little attention due to the apparently distracting nature of the cover photo.

In 2011, I wrote… A Picture’s Worth of Bias, in which I looked at a pretty common practice by the mainstream media: publishing stories on Republican politicians that feature highly unfavorable photos of them.

The latest example, back then, had come from a CNN online article on Bob Turner’s congressional win in New York, in which someone at the network seemed to have made a conscious decision to portray Turner as a maniacally laughing James Bond villain.

Other, more notable examples included Newsweek’s crazy-eyed cover photo of Republican Congresswoman Michele Bachmann (which even Jon Stewart took the magazine to task for, writing “Look Newsweek, that’s a s— picture of Michele Bachmann. And clearly not an accidentally bad picture of Michele Bachmann, because you could say a lot things about Michele Bachmann…a lot of things. But here’s what you can’t say about Michele Bachmann: That she’s not photogenic. Admit it Newsweek, you used that photo in a petty attempt to make Michele Bachmann look crazy…”) —

And the graphic ABC News chose to use for a 2008 story on presidential candidates Barack Obama and John McCain campaigning in Ohio. The faces of both men were superimposed over an outline of the state, with Obama smiling optimistically, and McCain scowling and shadowed from under a lifted black collar.

This is pretty ridiculous, even for Time. They would never portray a Democratic politician this way, unless maybe that politician had just been convicted of mass-murder.

As Jay Caruso pointed out on Twitter, this is the image Time used for former Attorney General Eric Holder back in 2014, in the magazine’s 100 Most Influential People issue:

President Barack Obama’s Attorney General, Eric Holder, from Time Magazine’s 100 Most Influential People of 2014.

Just a little bit different, I’d say. Biography-cover worthy, really.

This is political bias, plain and simple. If Time were upfront about that bias, and presented itself as an ideological publication that courts liberal readers, there wouldn’t be a whole lot to discuss here. Openly conservative publications like National Review and Weekly Standard publish unflattering cover imagery of political opponents all the time.

But Time still markets itself as a news source that doesn’t have any political skin in the game. Thus, stunts like this only serve to further damage the magazine’s credibility.

You’d think they’d be concerned about this, but like many in the news industry (unfortunately), they don’t seem to be.

Another photo of Jeff Sessions from the Time Magazine article:Jeff Sessions greets law-enforcement officers in Kentucky. Philip Montgomery for TIME

Questions

1. In his post, John Daly writes: “If Time were upfront about [its] bias, and presented itself as an ideological publication that courts liberal readers, there wouldn’t be a whole lot to discuss here. Openly conservative publications like National Review and Weekly Standard publish unflattering cover imagery of political opponents all the time. But Time still markets itself as a news source that doesn’t have any political skin in the game. Thus, stunts like this only serve to further damage the magazine’s credibility.” Do you agree with Mr. Daly’s assertion? Explain your answer.

2. Reacting to Time’s cover photo of Jeff Sessions, Democratic commentator Yashar Ali wrote in a tweet: “One of the things I really don’t like (and to the extent I can control it w/ my own stories, I do) is when news orgs pick unflattering photos to accompany their stories. There’s no reason for it..and it’s editorializing. If the person is bad news, let the story do the talking.” Do you agree with Mr. Ali’s assertion? Explain your answer.

3. Why do you think Time Magazine ran such an unflattering image of Jeff Sessions on its cover?


Scroll down to the bottom of the page for the answers.
























Answer(s)

Opinion questions. Answers vary.