"Say No to Digital ID" sprayed in Kingsway, Hove, England (Image: Eddie Mitchell)
redo Jump to...
print Print...
(by Caitlin McFall, Fox News) – The U.K.’s right and left-wing parties have reached an uncommon consensus: they oppose British Prime Minister Keir Starmer’s latest attempt to curb illegal immigration through mandatory digital ID cards.
The plan, announced last week and which will be fully rolled out by August 2029, revived a decades-old debate across the U.K. over whether digital IDs will be overly intrusive or even effective in combating illegal migration.
“You will not be able to work in the United Kingdom if you do not have digital ID. It’s as simple as that,” Starmer, leader of the Labour Party, said in announcing the compulsory plan.
But while illegal immigration has become an increasing concern across both sides of the aisle in the U.K., Starmer’s approach has been met with open opposition.
Former Labour Party leader Jeremy Corbyn, who left the party in 2024 to stand as an Independent, said he “firmly oppose[s] the government’s plans for compulsory digital ID cards.”
“This is an affront to our civil liberties, and will make the lives of minorities even more difficult and dangerous,” he said. “It is excessive state interference — and must be resisted.”
Corbyn, who this week launched his own political movement called “Your Party” as an alternative to what he called the “control freaks” of Labour, echoed similar criticism once voiced by right-wing leader Nigel Farage, who founded Reform UK in opposition to the Conservatives.
Farage, in a post on X, said he was also “firmly opposed” to the mandatory digital ID cards and argued, “It will make no difference to illegal immigration, but it will be used to control and penalize the rest of us.”
“The state should never have this much power,” he added.
While Starmer’s plan has drawn fire from both the left and right, albeit for very different reasons, polls suggest the public mood is also shifting.
The Independent reported that more than half of Brits backed digital IDs in June, with fewer than 20% opposed.
But that support appears to have drastically shifted, with nearly half of all Brits now saying they oppose the measure, according to the news outlet.
The digital ID card, which can be kept on a smartphone, would include a holder’s name, residency status, date of birth and nationality. British reports said it would initially be used only for employment verification, though its scope could be expanded.
The plan faces resistance: more than [2.8] million Brits have signed a petition on Parliament’s website opposing it, the BBC reported. Any petition with over 100,000 signatures must be considered for debate. [The population of the UK is 69 million].
The prime minister’s office could not be immediately reached for comment.
Published at Fox News on Oct. 2, 2025. Reprinted here for educational purposes only. May not be reproduced on other websites without permission.
Questions
NOTE: Before answering the questions, read the “Background” and watch the video under “Resources” below.
1. When will British citizens be required to have a Digital ID (the “Brit Card”)?
2. Keir Starmer is a leftist/socialist who after 2020 moved the Labour Party (which holds Socialist positions) to the left-center to increase candidates electability. What is his stated purpose for imposing mandatory Digital ID cards on anyone who wants to get a job, buy a house, get healthcare, etc…?
3. Close to 3 million Britons signed a petition opposing the mandatory Digital ID. Why are the left and right opposed to Starmer’s push to implement this plan?
4. a) What is supposed to happen when a petition to Parliament gets a certain number of signatures? Be specific.
b) How did Starmer’s majority Labour Party respond to the petition?
c) Why do you think this is so?
5. a) How has British support for / opposition to the Digital ID shifted over the past several months?
b) Why do you think this is so?
6. Consider the following “NoToDigitalID” X posts:
From Oct. 5:
Digital ID is not a left vs right issue.
It is freedom vs control.
Democracy vs authoritarianism.
Liberty vs constraint.
Left wing politics or right wing politics, we are in this together.
and also on Oct. 5:
Digital ID sounds convenient- until you realize what it costs.
A single login for everything means a single point of control.
Once your identity, finances, and access to services live in one digital profile, whoever controls that system controls you.
Privacy isn’t “old-fashioned.” It’s freedom.
Say no to digital ID.
Then watch the video under “Resources” with Louis Mosley, head of Palantir in the UK, who criticizes the government’s plan for mandatory Digital ID, stating it lacks a “clear public mandate,” and noting “It’s a program that needs to be decided at the ballot box, not in the company boardroom.”
Do you agree or disagree with these reasons for opposing Keir Starmer’s attempts to establish mandatory Digital ID on the citizens of the UK? Explain your answer.
CHALLENGE: The only way Keir Starmer can think of to curb illegal immigration in the UK is to try to make it hard for illegals to get jobs (and to jeopardize the freedom and privacy of citizens while doing so). List 2-3 other ways the UK could get people to stop people from coming into the country and/or working illegally.
Background
By collecting more than 100,000 signatures, the petition has surpassed the number required to be considered for debate in Parliament.
Government response: The government has issued a written response to the petition, stating they will proceed with the plan despite public opposition. However, after backlash, the government clarified that the digital ID would be mandatory for new employees to prove their right to work but would not need to be carried by individuals.
Concerns: Critics of the scheme, including civil liberties groups like Big Brother Watch, argue it is a step towards mass surveillance and government overreach. Some also doubt its effectiveness in tackling illegal immigration.
Political backdrop: The issue has sparked debate across the political spectrum, with opposition coming from both the left and right, including figures like Jeremy Corbyn and Nigel Farage. (Google AI Overview)
Resources
Palantir is a data analytics software company that builds platforms to help organizations integrate, manage, and secure vast amounts of data to gain insights and make better decisions. Watch the interview with Louis Mosley, head of Palantir in the UK, who criticizes the government’s plan for mandatory Digital ID, stating it lacks a “clear public mandate,” and noting “It’s a program that needs to be decided at the ballot box, not in the company boardroom.”
Daily “Answers” emails are provided for Daily News Articles, Tuesday’s World Events and Friday’s News Quiz.
