(by John Stossel, Townhall.com) – When you gas up your car, do you think that you’re doing something evil? After all, I’m told that burning gasoline helps “murder the Earth,” not to mention fills the coffers of terrorists and despots.
So we must move away from oil. Al Gore says, “The future of human civilization is at stake.”
But I need the gas. I need to drive. I need electricity to light my home. What can I do? Is there an alternative? There is, I’m told.
“What if we could use fuels that are not expensive, don’t cause pollution and are abundantly available right here at home? We have such fuels,” Gore says.
“In fact, we can start right now using solar power, wind power and geothermal power to make electricity for our homes and businesses.”
In 10 years, he says, we can get all our electricity from these carbon-free sources.
Global warming hysteria is just one reason Gore and others push for alternative fuels. We’re also told that America’s goal should be energy independence. Today, we do buy oil from some very nasty people: dictators in Venezuela and the Middle East. What if they cut us off? That fear is one reason almost every president and presidential candidate — from Richard Nixon to Barack Obama — promised to end our “intolerable” reliance on oil imports.
When Nixon was president, we imported 25 percent of our oil. Since then, our “leaders” have wasted billions on subsidies for alternative energy. The result? Today we import nearly 70 percent of our oil.
Terrible as that sounds, I say, “So what?” Interdependence is just fine! And journalist Robert Bryce, author of “Gusher of Lies: The Dangerous Delusion of Energy Independence,” agrees. He’ll be my guest on “Stossel” tomorrow night (Fox Business Network, 8 Eastern, and again Friday at 10).
Bryce points out that while Saudi Arabia and Iran are oil exporters, they are gasoline importers. “If even Saudi Arabia and Iran are energy interdependent, why wouldn’t we be?” he says. “Energy interdependence” is just a way of saying “division of labor” and “comparative advantage.”
Our biggest foreign oil suppliers are Canada and Mexico. Do they threaten us? Venezuela or Iran might, but they need the oil money. They would hurt themselves if they tried to cut us off.
Even if they did try, we’d still get their oil. All the world’s oil ends up in the same bathtub. The dictator sells to someone who sells to someone who will then sell to us. Chasing energy “independence” is pointless. Free trade is better. It makes us richer and more secure.
Yet among those pushing for subsidies, along with Gore, is someone smart: oil billionaire T. Boone Pickens. He’ll be a guest on my TV show, too.
You’ve probably seen Pickens in his television ads, saying: “I have a plan! We can unleash wind power to free up America’s natural gas to power our big trucks and bus fleets. And save billions of American dollars.”
But if we can save billions by using wind and natural gas, why do he, Vice President Gore and today’s Congress need our tax dollars? If there is a good alternative to oil, it won’t need subsidies. The free market will simply make it appear. Let the entrepreneurs compete.
Pickens’ commercials say: “Over $700 billion are leaving this country for foreign nations every year. That’s four times the cost of the Iraqi war. We need action.”
But that’s misleading. The $700 billion leave America for a reason. We get useful oil for the money. Trade is a win-win situation. There’s no comparison with destructive war spending.
Pickens’ website carries videos about how good government-subsidized windmills are for towns like Sweetwater, Texas.
Windmills may be great for Sweetwater, but that only looks at what’s seen. What’s unseen are all the people who are hurt because they are taxed to pay for Sweetwater’s windmills. That money could have gone elsewhere. It’s the broken-window fallacy identified by 19th-century French free-market economist Frederic Bastiat. Maybe Fox will let me break a window to make the point.
Pickens is wrong. We don’t need government to choose which fuels to subsidize. The free market is the way to go.
John Stossel is the New York Times best-selling author of Give Me A Break and Myths, Lies and Downright Stupidity. Mr. Stossel is a consumer reporter, investigative journalist, author, libertarian columnist, and former co-anchor for the ABC News show 20/20. In September 2009 Mr. Stossel left ABC News and joined Fox News Channel and Fox Business Network. Visit his blog at stossel.blogs.foxbusiness.com.
Copyright ©2010 Salem Web Network. All Rights Reserved. This article was first posted at Townhall.com on January 20, 2010. Reprinted here on January 21, 2010 for educational purposes only. May not be reproduced on other websites without permission from Salem Web Network.
NOTE: subsidy is defined by Merriam-Webster as: a grant [free money given] by a government to a private person or company to assist an enterprise deemed advantageous to the public
1. a) List the facts that John Stossel provides in his article. (scroll down for the answer)
b) Which of these did you not know? Which is most surprising to you? Why?
2. What is the main idea of Mr. Stossel’s commentary?
3. In an attempt to persuade Americans that the government should subsidize (give money to) his wind farm projects, T. Boone Pickens runs an ad which says “We can unleash wind power to free up America’s natural gas to power our [vehicles]. We can save billions.”
Mr. Stossel says, “But if we can save billions by using wind and natural gas, why do Boone Pickens, Vice President Gore and today’s Congress need our tax dollars? If there is a good alternative to oil, it won’t need subsidies. The free market will simply make it appear. Let the entrepreneurs compete.”
a) Do you agree with Mr. Stossel’s assertion? Explain your answer.
b) Ask a parent to answer the same question.
ANSWER TO QUESTION #1a:
- When Nixon was president, we imported 25 percent of our oil. (from para. 8)
- Today we import nearly 70 percent of our oil. (from para. 8)
- While Saudi Arabia and Iran are oil exporters, they are gasoline importers. (from para. 10)
- Our biggest foreign oil suppliers are Canada and Mexico. (from para. 11)
- All the world’s oil ends up in the same [place]. The dictator sells to someone who sells to someone who will then sell to us. (para. 12)