Details on Iran’s abuse of US sailors remain classified

Thursday's Editorial   —   Posted on May 19, 2016

Details on Iran’s abuse of US sailors remain classified

Iran forces U.S. soldiers to kneel in submission.

(by the New York Post editorial board) — If the American people knew the full — still classified — details of how Iran treated the US sailors it took captive last January, they’d be shocked.

So says a senior member of the House Armed Services Committee, who has received a “full classified briefing from military officials.”

We suspect Rep. Randy Forbes (R-Va.) is absolutely right. Because what’s already public is horrifying enough. Yet the public won’t learn the whole story for at least another year — well past November’s presidential election, Forbes told the Washington Free Beacon.

“I think that when the details actually come out,” he said, “most Americans are going to be kind of taken aback by the entire incident, both how Iran handled it and how we handled it.”

Again, it’s already an outrage. The Iranians ordered our sailors to kneel at gunpoint, parading them with hands in the air and forcing the lone woman to cover her hair, in accordance with their religious rules.

And they took photos and video of it all, as well as the commanding officer’s coerced apology. That’s multiple violations of international law — in just 15 hours of captivity that was itself illegal, since the sailors plainly veered into Iranian waters by accident.

Iran released photos of the US sailors they had captured.

Iran released photos of the US sailors they had captured.

Detained American Navy sailors in an undisclosed location in Iran

The only female sailor was forced to wear an Islamic headscarf.

Despite all that, Secretary of State John Kerry actually praised Iran for finally releasing its captives, calling it a “triumph of diplomacy.”

The only one who’s been held accountable? The officer in charge got dismissed from his post, it was disclosed last week.

His real crime, we suspect, was embarrassing President Obama just hours before the State of the Union address at which he’d planned to trumpet his nuclear deal with Iran. Last-minute complications were the last thing the White House wanted.

What’s the excuse for keeping the American people in the dark about the details now? It’s hard to see how the info can jeopardize national security — though it might foment even more opposition to Obama’s Iran giveaway.

Published May 17, 2016 at The New York Post. Reprinted here on May 19 for educational purposes only.

Questions

1. What is the main idea of this editorial?

2. As a senior member of the U.S. House Armed Services Committee, Rep. Randy Forbes (R-Va.) has been briefed on confidential (classified) details of Iran taking captive U.S. sailors who had accidentally strayed into Iranian waters. What does Rep. Forbes say about the information he received?

3. What information do we currently know about the incident?

4. The editors concludes by asking:

“What’s the excuse for keeping the American people in the dark about the details now (by keeping them classified [secret])? It’s hard to see how the info can jeopardize national security.”

a) Do you agree or disagree with this assertion? Explain your answer.
b) What do you think is the Obama administration’s motive for keeping this information classified?


Resources

Read about Iran’s capture of our U.S. sailors.

Read about Ben Rhodes, 38, deputy national security adviser for strategic communications. He writes the president’s speeches, plans his trips abroad and runs communications strategy across the White House. He is…the single most influential voice shaping American foreign policy aside from President Obama himself.
On May 6, 2016 The New York Times posted an interview with Ben Rhodes: “Top Obama Aide Used False Narrative to Sell Iran Nuclear Deal” (Read the full article here)