CIA Interrogations

Friday's Editorial Cartoon   —   Posted on August 28, 2009

Question(s)

1. a) To what recent controversy does this cartoon refer?
b) Describe some different opinions on this issue.
c) What is your opinion on the issue of interrogating terrorism suspects?

Scroll down to the bottom of the page for the answers.
























Answer(s)

1. a) This cartoon refers to the controversy over the types of interrogation methods the CIA uses to extract information from terrorism suspects.b)  Different opinions on this issue include:

  • No harsh interrogation methods should be used on suspects, even to gather evidence that would save American lives from terrorist attacks. (Liberals generally support this belief.)
  • Water-boarding is torture and should not be used, even to prevent further terrorist attacks on Americans.
  • Water-boarding is not torture, so it is ok to used this method to get information from terrorists to prevent planned attacks. (Conservatives generally support this belief.)
  • Even if water-boarding is torture, it should be used on terrorist suspects to gain information to prevent terrorist attacks.  Saving American lives is more important than how we treat captured terrorists.
  • That as unlawful combatants, terrorists do not fall under the Geneva convention and therefore are not entitled to be treated as Prisoners of War.

c)  Opinion question. Answers vary.

 

Read an editorial on this topic at The Washington Times.